Last week while I was reading and grading final assignments for the course I teach at a local university, an e-mail popped into my box from one of the students---a part-time student with a full time, demanding job. She explained that she was traveling for work and had written the assignment in transit. She had intended to post it during a stopover in Chicago or Frankfurt, but the flight connection was too tight in Chicago, and when she got to Frankfurt it was impossible to get a good internet connection. So she sent me a quick note from her phone with an appeal for some "Christmas grace."
I looked at her grade without the assignment, a "B,"and calculated what it would be if she completed the assignment as intended, an "A." Grades were due at 5:00 pm that day, so I quickly decided to post the grade as "I" (Incomplete) and offer to adjust it once she delivers the missing work. You see, at this particular university I, as the instructor, have the ability to simply change an "I" to a letter grade online. Changing a "B" to an "A" requires filling out some paperwork, delivering it to the school, and requesting the signature of someone with more authority than myself. It also requires that I explain "what happened" and why I think the grade change is justified in this case.
So, an Incomplete grade serves my needs (and the students', I think) best at this moment in time.
It also prompts me to consider all of the other times when being satisfied with an "incomplete" would serve me (maybe all of us?) better than striving for an "A" or some other "grade" that we might give ourselves or expect from someone else.
When I was struggling to finish my masters' thesis 10 years ago, one of my advisors shared a piece of wisdom that really helped. She told me there are two kinds of thesis projects, "perfect" and "finished," and that I would have to choose which one I wanted. Of course I chose to finish, and still cringe that it wasn't perfect, but I've carried this lesson with me and can see that I still need to remember it today.
So as I write this blog every week, I'm going to try hard to be satisfied with "incomplete." I'll press the "post" button before I know that what I've written is perfect, and see what happens. Maybe I'll publish some articles and books somewhere else that will be more "complete" and worthy of a letter grade from someone, but here I won't worry about finishing anything.
I do hope to start some things, though....